Can Cardinals be Pets? The Legal and Ethical Dilemma

Can Cardinals Be Pets? A Comprehensive Guide

Cardinals, with their vibrant red plumage and enchanting songs, are a sight to behold in nature. Many bird enthusiasts may wonder if these beautiful creatures can be kept as pets.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of cardinals, their legal status as pets, and the ethical implications of keeping them in captivity.

The Cardinal Bird: An Overview

The Cardinal bird, also known as the Northern Cardinal, is a songbird native to North and South America.

Known for their bright red color, especially in males, cardinals are a favorite among bird watchers. They are medium-sized birds, with a body length of 8.3–9.1 in and a wingspan of 9.8–12.2 in.

Cardinals are known for their distinctive crest, a feature found in both males and females.

While males are predominantly red with black mask on their faces, females sport a more subdued shade of brownish-red.

The cardinal bird habitat ranges from woodlands and gardens to shrublands and wetlands.

They are non-migratory birds, meaning they establish territories and spend their entire lives within a few kilometers of their birthplace.

The Legal Status of Cardinals as Pets

When it comes to keeping cardinals as pets, the law is clear. The Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918 prohibits the capture, possession, buying, selling, or trading of native birds, including cardinals, in the United States.

This law was enacted to protect native bird species from extinction due to commercial trade.

The Act is not exclusive to the United States. It’s an international agreement between the U.S., Canada, Mexico, Japan, and Russia.

Therefore, the legal status of cardinals as pets extends beyond U.S. borders, making it illegal in these countries as well.

In addition to the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, many states have their own laws and regulations regarding the possession of wild birds.

For instance, in some states, it’s illegal to keep a cardinal as a pet, even if you found it injured or orphaned.

While the law is clear, enforcement can be challenging. Penalties for violating the Act can range from fines to imprisonment, depending on the severity of the offense.

However, it’s essential to remember that these laws are in place to protect our native bird species and their habitats.

In conclusion, while cardinals are beautiful and fascinating creatures, they are best admired in their natural habitats.

The legal and ethical implications of keeping them as pets are significant, and it’s our responsibility as nature lovers to respect and protect these magnificent birds.

The Ethics of Keeping Cardinals as Pets

Beyond the legal implications, there are significant ethical considerations when it comes to keeping cardinals as pets.

Wild birds, including cardinals, are not domesticated animals.

They have evolved over millions of years to live in specific natural environments, and their physical, behavioral, and psychological health is intimately tied to these environments.

In captivity, cardinals are denied the ability to fly freely, forage for their food, and engage in their natural behaviors.

This can lead to a range of problems, including stress, boredom, and a decrease in physical health.

Moreover, cardinals are social creatures. In the wild, they live in flocks and have complex social interactions. In captivity, these social needs are often unmet, leading to further stress and behavioral issues.

In essence, the impact of captivity on a cardinal’s behavior and well-being can be severe, leading to a diminished quality of life.

As such, the ethical implications of keeping cardinals as pets are significant and cannot be ignored.

Alternatives to Keeping Cardinals as Pets

While it’s clear that keeping cardinals as pets is both illegal and unethical, there are ways to enjoy these beautiful birds without causing them harm. Here are some alternatives:

  • Creating a bird-friendly garden: Plant native trees and shrubs that provide food and shelter for cardinals. You can also install bird feeders and bird baths to attract them.
  • Bird watching: Instead of keeping cardinals in cages, consider taking up bird watching. This allows you to observe and appreciate cardinals in their natural habitat.
  • Supporting conservation efforts: Many organizations work to protect and conserve bird species and their habitats. You can support these efforts through donations or volunteer work.

By choosing these alternatives, you can enjoy the beauty and charm of cardinals without compromising their well-being. It’s a win-win situation for both you and the birds!

Understanding Cardinal Behavior

Cardinals are known for their unique behaviors, which make them fascinating to observe. One of the most notable aspects of cardinal behavior is their bonding with humans.

While they are wild birds, cardinals have been known to form connections with people who regularly feed them or provide bird-friendly habitats.

Cardinals are also territorial birds, especially during the breeding season. Males are known to be particularly aggressive in defending their territories.

They have been observed attacking their reflections in windows and car mirrors, mistaking them for rival males.

Despite their occasional aggression, cardinals are generally peaceful birds. They have a complex social structure and communicate using a variety of songs and calls.

Understanding these behaviors can enhance our appreciation of these beautiful birds and inform our interactions with them.

Cardinal Care and Habitat

While it’s illegal and unethical to keep cardinals as pets, you can create a suitable environment in your yard to attract and support these birds.

Planting native trees and shrubs, providing fresh water, and offering bird-friendly food in feeders can make your yard a haven for cardinals.

If you find an injured or orphaned cardinal, it’s important not to try to care for the bird yourself. Instead, contact a local wildlife rehabilitator or bird rescue organization.

They have the knowledge and resources to provide appropriate care and, if possible, return the bird to the wild.

Summary

Cardinals are beautiful, fascinating birds that are best appreciated in their natural habitats.

While the idea of keeping a cardinal as a pet may be tempting, it’s important to understand that this is both illegal and unethical.

Instead, we can create bird-friendly environments in our yards, enjoy bird watching, and support conservation efforts.

By doing so, we can enjoy the beauty and charm of cardinals without compromising their well-being. It’s a win-win situation for both us and the birds!

FAQs

Do cardinals bond with humans?

Yes, cardinals can form bonds with humans, especially if the person regularly feeds them or provides a bird-friendly habitat.

Can a cardinal live in captivity?

While cardinals can physically survive in captivity, it’s both illegal and unethical to keep them as pets. Captivity can have a negative impact on their physical, behavioral, and psychological health.

How much does a cardinal bird cost?

As it’s illegal to buy or sell cardinals, there is no legitimate cost for these birds.

Do the Cardinals get aggressive?


Male cardinals can become aggressive during the breeding season when defending their territories. However, they are generally peaceful birds.


Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *